🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Thread View: comp.sys.ibm.pc.games.strategic
5 messages
5 total messages Started by fv... Fred Voss Tue, 23 Nov 1993 14:09
Review of Gettysburg by Swift??
#1
Author: fv... Fred Voss
Date: Tue, 23 Nov 1993 14:09
6 lines
671 bytes
CompUSA had an ad for this game recently. Can anyone provide
details on the game?

Thanks,

Fred Voss
Re: Review of Gettysburg by Swift??
#2
Author: gand... gary anderson
Date: Tue, 23 Nov 1993 17:39
37 lines
2770 bytes
fv...@pyrite.nj.pyramid.com (Fred Voss) writes:

>CompUSA had an ad for this game recently. Can anyone provide
>details on the game?

Negatives first:  It has a single-screen non-zoomable map of the 
Gettysburg field, so abandon any ideas of close-tactical escapades like 
the 20th Maine's on Little Round Top.  The AI (and the manual as much as 
admits this) can do some rather weird things when playing in the 
'non-historical' mode.  And the program installed *lots* of pictures 
of commanders (.BMP), but I have yet to see even one picture (aside 
from Lee and Meade) during the course of many playings.  (I may be 
missing something, but I couldn't find anything about them in the manual...)

On the plus side:  it is *not* a slavish imitation of a hex-board 
game, so all the artificial movement-point-counting and 
strength-point-counting is thankfully absent.  It is played in 'real 
time' (though speeded up, of course), so there are no 'turns.'  
Weaponry, terrain, fatigue, morale are all taken into account, but 
leadership factors are either abstracted or non-existent.  The sound effects, 
while not necessary to the game, are very good and really add some 
texture -- the battle sounds are sensational, and during night hours, you 
hear a plantive harmonica and crickets, and campfires flicker on the map.
(This is with a soundboard -- there is no sound if you just have 
internal PC speakers.)

The main strength of this thing, I think, is in its historical replay 
function.  When you just let it play (in demo mode, as it were), and 
read the many historical notes that pop up, you get a very good model 
of the battle and a real sense of the ebb and flow of the fighting.  
One interesting feature you can toggle is a graphic of where 
casualties are happening -- or dead bodies, if you will.  After the 
battle you can easily see where fighting was the fiercest.  You can take 
command of one side or the other and try alternative strategies if you 
wish, but as I said I'm suspicious of the AI (so far, anyway).  I would 
recommend this to a student of the battle; but not necessarily to someone 
looking for a 'game.'
Re: Review of Gettysburg by Swift??
#3
Author: du... James Dusek
Date: Tue, 23 Nov 1993 18:19
14 lines
1366 bytes
In article <2ct5jm$j...@pyrite.nj.pyramid.com>, fv...@pyrite.nj.pyramid.com
(Fred Voss) wrote:
> CompUSA had an ad for this game recently. Can anyone provide
> details on the game?

	Pretty good game platform, but there is NO AI at all. You need two 
people to play it. Otherwise it is pretty good.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
| James Dusek               |    ______    ------            _____ |
| Motorola CSC              |    |    |    |    |    ______  |   | |
| Rolling Meadows,Il        |~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|
|du...@cadsun.corp.mot.com  |                                      |
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Re: Review of Gettysburg by Swift??
#4
Author: gand... gary anderson
Date: Wed, 24 Nov 1993 05:37
13 lines
1124 bytes
du...@cadsun.corp.mot.com (James Dusek) writes:

>In article <2ct5jm$j...@pyrite.nj.pyramid.com>, fv...@pyrite.nj.pyramid.com
>(Fred Voss) wrote:
>> CompUSA had an ad for this game recently. Can anyone provide
>> details on the game?

>	Pretty good game platform, but there is NO AI at all. You need two 
>people to play it.

Not so! You *can* play versus the computer, though the AI is, shall we
say, no R. E. Lee.  But it's certainlyworth a look, if you're a 
Gettysburg aficionado.
Re: Review of Gettysburg by Swift??
#5
Author: andrewleo.harrington
Date: Mon, 27 May 2013 01:50
7 lines
1566 bytes
On Tuesday, November 23, 1993 10:27:18 AM UTC-5, Fred Voss wrote:
> CompUSA had an ad for this game recently. Can anyone provide
> details on the game?
> 
> Thanks,
> 
> Fred Voss
Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads