🚀 go-pugleaf

On Tue, 3 Mar 1998 thya...@sol.com.br wrote:

> 
> 
>   So what does that say about me?  I'm not the one being hypocritical, trying
> to protect a guy who obviously just wants to bad-mouth a person when the
> defendant has done nothing to him. I find THAT despicable.  He may not like
> her games, but millions have played them, and enjoyed them.
> 
> >>>>>>> Bad-mouth? Ok, I've never played any of those games, I just didn't
> like her face and thought I could have fun by making up things about
> Phantasmagoria and KQ. And, guess what, the design faults I made up for KQ6
> actually exist! Gee, what a coincidence.

What deisgn fault?  You DON'T need the lamp to finish the game!!!! I have
stated that MANY times before!  There are 4 ways to finish the game, and
if you missed something, you could always use another route to pass.  So I
DON'T think the "design" flaw you mention DOES exist.  

Well, the tone of your post seemed like what you just mentioned above.
Also, you dismissed her, yet you say you haven't played all her games.
Now, if you played ALL of them and hated all, then it's different.  But
NOT playing all her games and then saying she is talentless, I'm sorry.
You just DON'T qualify to make that judgement.  what happened if you
played some game of hers later and liked it?  Well, that defeats
everything you've said, doesn't it?
 
>   Saying that her games suck implies that we all have no taste in gaming.
> What an insult.
> 
> >>>>>>>> It doesn't imply anything. It clearly says I don't like her work.
> Period. "We all" surely doesn't fit - I'm not alone here. And if you come out
> and say that Civilzation or Le Chuck's Revenge were lousy games, I won't be
> insulted at all. I'll just have to disagree.

I wouldn't say either were lousy...although I think Monkey Island II was
nowhere near as good as the original.  That damn
monocle-asd-replacement-for-eye-that-sees-the-world puzzle STILLL
infuriates me.  Now THAT was an example of an obscure puzzle.

Raymond
 
> 
> -----== Posted via Deja News, The Leader in Internet Discussion ==-----
> http://www.dejanews.com/   Now offering spam-free web-based newsreading
> 
>