🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Thread View: alt.games.lucas-arts.monkey-island
5 messages
5 total messages Started by neppie Thu, 15 Oct 2009 17:55
Actually on topic....
#241845
Author: neppie
Date: Thu, 15 Oct 2009 17:55
12 lines
1744 bytes
Is anyone really enjoying the new MI episodes?  I've played all three so 
far, and while the first one was fun - even funny - the second one was 
abysmal and the third was kinda lame.  The only redeeming thing in 3 was 
MURRAY.  The puzzles are way too easy, too.
Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I don't like the talking much.  I liked 
leaving things to my imagination.  *sigh*  It's SUPER annoying in these 
installments, particularly.

/rant
Not really, but I don't want to bore you.

Not that I could in this place...no one else is talking about anything. 
Re: Actually on topic....
#241846
Author: Rasmus Bøg Hansen
Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2009 19:48
24 lines
1807 bytes
neppie skrev:
> Is anyone really enjoying the new MI episodes?  I've played all three so 
> far, and while the first one was fun - even funny - the second one was 
> abysmal and the third was kinda lame.  The only redeeming thing in 3 was 
> MURRAY.  The puzzles are way too easy, too.
> Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I don't like the talking much.  I 
> liked leaving things to my imagination.  *sigh*  It's SUPER annoying in 
> these installments, particularly.

I have only played through 1/3 of the second one (or something like 
that) and I like it until now.

I might be out of training by not playing computer games for some years, 
but I did in general find the puzzles appropriate...

> Not that I could in this place...no one else is talking about anything.

People are just whispering VERY quiet...

-- 
-- [ Rasmus "Møffe" Bøg Hansen ] -------------------------------------
When is it time to reinstall an operation system?
- When booted, the computer prints "Starting Windows..."
----------------------------------------------[ moffe at zz9 dot dk ] --
Re: Actually on topic....
#241847
Author: neppie
Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2009 01:50
29 lines
2610 bytes

"Rasmus Bøg Hansen" <spam09@zz9.dk> wrote in message 
news:4adf658a$0$36565$edfadb0f@dtext01.news.tele.dk...
> neppie skrev:
>> Is anyone really enjoying the new MI episodes?  I've played all three so 
>> far, and while the first one was fun - even funny - the second one was 
>> abysmal and the third was kinda lame.  The only redeeming thing in 3 was 
>> MURRAY.  The puzzles are way too easy, too.
>> Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I don't like the talking much.  I liked 
>> leaving things to my imagination.  *sigh*  It's SUPER annoying in these 
>> installments, particularly.
>
> I have only played through 1/3 of the second one (or something like that) 
> and I like it until now.
>
> I might be out of training by not playing computer games for some years, 
> but I did in general find the puzzles appropriate...

Oh, I failed to mention that the first game had good puzzles.  The second 
starts out decent, but then becomes very LAME (a lot of running between 
islands, back and forth, back and forth).  You will see, once you get to the 
other 2/3 of it.  Third game...way too easy.

>> Not that I could in this place...no one else is talking about anything.
>
> People are just whispering VERY quiet...

They need to speak up.  They are pissing me off! 
Re: Actually on topic....
#241848
Author: Daffy
Date: Sat, 24 Oct 2009 14:06
27 lines
2355 bytes
neppie doesn't look like a skull at all:

>>> Is anyone really enjoying the new MI episodes?  I've played all three 
>>> so far, and while the first one was fun - even funny - the second one 
>>> was abysmal and the third was kinda lame.  The only redeeming thing 
>>> in 3 was MURRAY.  The puzzles are way too easy, too.
>>> Maybe I'm just old fashioned, but I don't like the talking much.  I 
>>> liked leaving things to my imagination.  *sigh*  It's SUPER annoying 
>>> in these installments, particularly.
>>
>> I have only played through 1/3 of the second one (or something like 
>> that) and I like it until now.
>>
>> I might be out of training by not playing computer games for some 
>> years, but I did in general find the puzzles appropriate...
> 
> Oh, I failed to mention that the first game had good puzzles.  The 
> second starts out decent, but then becomes very LAME (a lot of running 
> between islands, back and forth, back and forth).  You will see, once 
> you get to the other 2/3 of it.  Third game...way too easy.

Too easy is right. The puzzles in Ep 1 reminded me too much of EMI 
though, so I can't agree with you there.

I'm enjoying the story (and characters) though, it seems to have adapted 
well to the episodic format. We can only hope the puzzles get harder in 
the later episodes.
Re: Actually on topic....
#241849
Author: neppie
Date: Sun, 25 Oct 2009 02:34
29 lines
2603 bytes

"Daffy" <daffy@imalga.net> wrote in message 
news:02f2f880$0$1280$c3e8da3@news.astraweb.com...
> neppie doesn't look like a skull at all:

<snip>

>> Oh, I failed to mention that the first game had good puzzles.  The second 
>> starts out decent, but then becomes very LAME (a lot of running between 
>> islands, back and forth, back and forth).  You will see, once you get to 
>> the other 2/3 of it.  Third game...way too easy.
>
> Too easy is right. The puzzles in Ep 1 reminded me too much of EMI though, 
> so I can't agree with you there.

Still had to think a little outside the box to solve them.  The puzzle 
solutions were amusing, in keeping with the game, but yes, not particularly 
hard.  They definitely need to step it up - I feel as if this is some $ 
scheme, rather than an homage to one of the greatest games evAr!!

>
> I'm enjoying the story (and characters) though, it seems to have adapted 
> well to the episodic format. We can only hope the puzzles get harder in 
> the later episodes.

They could have done far worse with the characters and the VAs, for sure.  I 
just wish they wouldn't have made some of the dialogue and sounds so 
repetitve. 
Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads